Houston Astros ace Justin Verlander added to his already lengthy Hall of Fame résumé on Wednesday, when he was announced as this year’s American League Cy Young Award winner, edging teammate Gerrit Cole.
Verlander received 17 first-place votes compared to 13 for Cole in balloting by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America announced Wednesday. Tampa Bay Rays righty Charlie Morton finished third a year after leaving Houston in free agency.
Results are tabulated on a system that rewards seven points for first place, four points for second place, three points for third place, two votes for fourth place and one point for fifth place.
Verlander, 36, became the 20th pitcher to win multiple Cy Young Awards. He won in 2011 with Detroit after a season for which he also took home AL MVP honors. The seven years between Cy Young wins is the longest span in the history of the award.
Verlander went 21-6 while leading the AL in wins and innings pitched (223). He finished second to Cole in ERA (2.58) and strikeouts (300).
The 300-strikeout season was the first of Verlander’s illustrious career. He struck out his 3,000th career hitter in his final regular-season start against the Angels on Sept. 28, becoming the 18th pitcher to reach that milestone. On Sept. 1, he became the sixth pitcher to throw at least three no-hitters with his 14-strikeout no-no at Toronto.
That’s not bad for a power pitcher in his 15th season.
“I guess the hunger just comes from me,” Verlander said during the postseason. “Just comes from within. The will, the urge to want to be the best I can be. So I’m going to continue to strive to do that.”
Verlander and Don Newcombe are the only players to have won Rookie of the Year, a Cy Young Award and MVP.
Verlander teamed with Cole to become the first duo to each win 20 games and strike out 300 batters for the same team. Verlander is the fourth Astros pitcher to win a Cy Young Award and the second since Houston moved to the American League. Dallas Keuchel took AL honors in 2015, and Roger Clemens (2004) and Mike Scott (1986) won the award when the Astros were in the National League.
With New York’s CC Sabathia retiring, Verlander becomes the active leader in most major pitching categories. His 225 wins are 20 more than that of teammate Zack Greinke, and his 3,006 strikeouts are 314 more than that of Washington’s Max Scherzer. Verlander is also the career leader in innings (2,982), starts (453) and wins above replacement for pitchers (71.4).
The only blotch on Verlander’s 2019 record was the continuation of his long-standing troubles in the World Series. He lost both of his starts against the Washington Nationals, giving up seven runs in 11 innings. Verlander is 0-6 with a 5.68 ERA in seven Fall Classic starts — the most winless starts by a pitcher in Series history.
For all he has done, Verlander might be at it for a while. He reiterated a couple of times this season that he’s still hoping to ply his trade until age 45, which would put him well in line to become baseball’s next 300-game winner.
2019 American League Cy Young Voting
|Eduardo Rodriguez/Red Sox||–||–||–||3||2||8|
|Lucas Giolito/White Sox||–||–||–||–||8||8|
|— Baseball Writers’ Association of America|
“You never know,” Verlander said. “I know the fire is still there. The competitiveness is still there. And as long as that’s there, I’m going to try to just thrive as long as I can.”
Cole, 29, went 20-5 while leading the AL in ERA (2.50) and strikeouts (326), the latter the most in baseball since Randy Johnson struck out 334 in 2002. But he was more than pure power: Cole walked just 48 batters on the season, giving him a remarkable 6.79 strikeouts for every walk.
The breakout season continued a career resurgence for Cole that began when he was acquired in a 2018 trade by the Astros from the Pittsburgh Pirates, who drafted him first overall in the 2011 draft. Cole was 59-42 with a 3.50 ERA and 8.4 strikeouts per nine innings at the time of the trade. During two seasons with the analytics-driven Astros, he went 35-10 with a 2.68 ERA and 13.1 strikeouts per nine innings.
After losing to the White Sox on May 22, Cole began a remarkable streak that lasted all the way to Game 1 of the World Series. He went 25 starts without a loss, including the postseason, going 19-0 in that span, with a 1.59 ERA and 258 strikeouts in 169⅓ innings. Finally, his streak was broken when he lost to the Nationals on Oct. 22.
Cole became a free agent after the season, and based on his age and the strength of his past two campaigns, it is widely believed that Cole will land the largest pitching contract in baseball history.
Morton, who turned 36 on Tuesday, provided crucial stability for a Rays rotation that was beset by injuries. Morton’s 194⅔ innings were 53 more than that of any other pitcher on the Tampa Bay staff. Among the injured was lefty Blake Snell, who took home AL Cy Young honors in 2018 before being limited to 107 innings in 23 starts this season.
Of course, you don’t become a Cy Young finalist based on innings alone. Morton went 16-6, setting a career mark for wins, and posted personal bests in ERA (3.05) and strikeouts (240). The strong campaign continued a late-career surge for the righty, who had won 10 games just once in his first nine big league seasons. He has won at least 14 games in each of the past three seasons.
Morton teamed with Verlander and Cole in the Astros’ rotation after the latter was acquired in 2018. He left Houston after the season for a two-year, $30 million deal with the Rays.
The Associated Press contributed to this report.